Hypocrisy much?


It’s day 3 of my 3rd week without my laptop. I’m ok with it so far, in fact I’m feeling better. The laptop repair is done but I’m just waiting for my friend to give it back to me. I hope I don’t get back to my old head-glued-to-the-laptop-till-after-midnight routine. I’ll have to work on this.

Apart from that, Lebanese movies are rocking the theaters.

If you watch TV you’ll find that there are around 3-4 movies. This started last year with Nadine Labaki’s hit movie “Where Do We Go Now” but no one has yet been able to dethrone her, yet some were able to cause some controversy. I’m referring here to Joe Bou Eid’s new movie “Tannoura Maxi” that has been taking mixed reviews from the Lebanese audience. The movie was released some two weeks ago. The publicity and branding that surrounded the movie before the release were huge, but it was rumored that it’s only because it would not gather much audience as anticipated. People did watch the movie, and were it a valid policy here, some would claim a refund. Other liked it and went well with the story of Joe’s parents and how they met during the times of war in Lebanon.

Out of the whole movie, which I didn’t watch yet, a certain TV presenter decided to make a fuzz about one scene. He decided to go all religious on that particular scene where the priest-to-be, Joe’s father, is fighting temptation that a beautiful strange girl, Joe’s mother, who came to the village had caused to him. The scene is expressed by a dance at the church. The presenter is claiming that the scene is obscene and erotic and it shouldn’t be allowed because of it distorts the image of the church and clergy. I will not be attacking the presenter, who also didn’t watch the movie. And I won’t be defending it either. Not until I watch it and see for myself how offending it is.

The movie might very offending, but so is lots of other things. Let’s talk first about things that took place in Lebanese movies first. How come no one said a word about Labaki’s movie being offending? (I read a few, but they didn’t cause a stir) Why wasn’t anyone offended by Muslims smashing the statue of Virgin Mary? Why wasn’t anyone offended by mocking her? Why wasn’t anyone offended by having goats in the mosque chewing on holy books? Why didn’t the clergy men get offended by the runaway priest and sheikh who accompanied the Ukrainian girls? Why wasn’t anyone offended by having women changing their religion and being rebellious?

All these questions came to my mind, why this and not that? Why is Nadine Labaki about to replace the cedar tree on the flag and Joe is getting all this opposition. I still don’t know how much he deserves to be opposed but it shouldn’t be this way. From the review I read, the movie has technical errors (which lots of Hollywood movies have, but still not an excuse) and the story is a bit loose. Well, if its a bad movie, give it a low rating and move on.

To me, cinema isn’t about idealism. It’s not an outlet to preach. It’s for expressing ideas and thoughts. It’s a way of expression just like painting, theater, books, graffiti,… It represents and reflects the creator of the work.

To come to a conclusion, I’d like to ask the presenter and those who backed him up to care more about issue that are actually harming religions like the behavior, claims and statements that their men (because it’s mostly men) are making that are ruining their reputations and positions.


8 thoughts on “Hypocrisy much?

  1. About the why ‘Tannoura Maxi’ but now ‘Where Do We Go Now?’, I say that it’s because ‘Maxi’ gives a bad image on the Lebanese Forces. I bet that if it wasn’t for politics, the religion wouldn’t have made such a big deal out of it.
    I have seen both movies, and Nadine Labaki’s movie does “offend” religion WAY more than Joe Bou Eid’s – if you want to look at it their way. But off course, people have to start making a difference between real life and movies. Movies should be able to deal with all kind of subjects, in any way the director feels it fits in the movie, without religion, politics or anyone interfering and censuring anything.

    • If so, why didn’t the Lebanese forces (or their supporters who talk in their name) start the campaign against it? Why does it have to be a tv presenter? What does he have to do with either religions and politics? Who died and made him responsible?

      I still havent watch the movie, so i cant judge. But I have to say, im against the banning that is being talked about

  2. watching it from outside, i’m interested and shocked at the same time, i mean can a tv presenter whoever he is move all this? but the sad thing as everybody here mentioned, is people making a fuss on a single movie when the real problems are outside theaters…

    • Well the only reason it caused all this because he contacted religious figures who have not watched the movie and tried to come up with theories and ask the authorities to ban the movie.
      The movie passed through the general security and is now public. And as I was discussing this situation over social media, I came to thought that this whole fuzz is to shush people and limit their freedom from exposing too much.
      As you said, the problem is not with the movie, its with what’s happening in real life. I read an article supporting the movie and stating that if a single movie, better yet, a scene would cause people to lose faith, then the problem is not with the movie, it’s with the weak faith of the audience.

      • totally agreeing on the faith thingy…
        and once again it’s a matter for the evil twins: power and control…passing through politics or religion the results stay the same. i might sound kind of an anarchist here, which i’m not, but it’s undeniable the effect that power and control have on some categories

  3. maybe nadine has a wasta ??
    tannoura maxi is bullshit ! its a copy cat of nadine’s style. what a creative guy joe bou eid !

    • i once heard a comment that Nadine Labaki got away with it because her film’s production is French.
      And about Tannoura Maxi, I can’t reply to your opinion. Each one takes it in his/her own perspective.

      Have you read my review?

Share Your Thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s